Title
Native American Sacred Sites

The Discovery of Human Remains in Sacramento County from 1994-2004

Author


Sharon Cearley

American River College Geography 350: Data Acquisition in GIS; Fall 2005

Contact Information: 4255 Winding Way #10, 916-484-6964,

sharoncearley350@hotmail.com

Abstract


The object of this paper is to provide the representative agency, Native American Heritage Commission, with spatial properties of their data in order to facilitate the operation of the agency in the fulfillment of the mission. The project methods were to acquire data on human remains from

public records, refine the data for mapable coordinates, organize into electronic format, and using ESRI software geocode to a simple map of Sacramento County. The actual data will be kept confidential.

Introduction

Native American heritage commission was formed in 1977.  NAHC has as its mission focus: consultations between tribes and state,  federal and local agencies and developers regarding Native American human remains, religious and ceremonial resources and sites, and to identify the

most likely descendants of burial finds. Presently databases maintained are the Sacred Lands Inventory and Request for Assistance. NAHC does not keep information as spatial statistics.

The NAHC needs to have sites of recovered remains mapped for use as presentation value and to give information about trends of locations, the topological relationships between sites and the sacred lands, and as a predictor for future human remains being found. I conducted research on

behalf of the Native American Heritage Commission as a class project to record spatial data on Native American burial discoveries in Sacramento County from 1995 to present. I acquired data from the County Coroner’s office of the locations of the sites of human remains recovered, and

joined it with data on most likely descendant, final disposition, and the relationship to sacred land sites, converting it to a compatible format to use by ArcGIS software. My intention for this project was to be of service to the Native American Community by providing a technology to the NAHC that was perceived as needed.

Background

A new law protects information that could reveal locations of tribal burial grounds and other sacred sites in California, which many tribes keep under wraps because of fears of vandalism and theft. Glenn Villa the head of the Cultural Resources for the Ione Band of Miwok Indians said, “I

don’t think those sites really need to be written about in the newspaper.” he was quoted in an article of the Sacramento News and Review (Garvin, Cosmo. What lies beneath-From Prehistoric Cultures to Pioneer Artifacts. Sacramento News/Review, September 15, 2003.) Those sentiments sum up the pervasive opinions of the tribe members on the subject. Some information has been published about locations of Cultural Resources as an effort to educate the public.  Very few little has been published giving locations of Native American sacred sites. Strap Ravine Nisenan Maidu Indian Site in Roseville is listed, described in a publication from 1973 and Indian Stone Corral in Orangevale is listed from a publication in 1975. Both were found in a search of a database from the USGS Archeology site. Tribal leaders are reluctant to talk about it. Research revealed only two sites in Sacramento County, both not revealing the specific address. In History of a Central California Site: Or What Happened at King Brown, William H.Olsen describes the excavation and abandonment of an archeological site threatened during construction of Sacramento State College in 1954-1956.The excavation was rescinded due to the imminence of the construction program. In the fall of 1956, the site was partially leveled for streets and residential construction. The original finds occurred on he site of the Sacramento Junior College in 1939 and 1940 but were never

officially recorded. Both state and federal governments have recognized the importance of protecting our cultural resources. Federal laws govern the operations of Agencies such as the US Department of Fish and Game, The USGS, and the Department of Forestry. Some of the California State laws are:

      6254: California Public Records Act

      65092: Public notice to California Native American Indian Tribes

      65351, 65352.3-65352.4:Consultations with Native Americans on General Plan Proposals

      65560,65562.5:Consultations with Native Americans on Open Space

      50280-50290:Mills Act (Historical Property Contracts)

      

These codes provide the process for consultations, notifications and negotiations for public agencies and private owners to provide California Native American Tribes their rights to preserve the cultural sites and the return of discovered remains. The map below is from an internet site mapping inexact locations of threatened sites in Orange County. Pictured below is a bedrock mortar site in Rancho Murieta area.

Methods

To preserve privacy I was asked to obtain the records of human remains discoveries for public record. After many phone calls, emails and two faxes and a trip to the Coroners office, 4800 Broadway, I acquired a typed three page list of locations from the County Coroner, Ed Smith. Only six of the 32 discoveries had street addresses. I populated an excel spreadsheet with the data I received, using the addresses I was given. I gave the fields titles based on the categories of the data and using Google Earth internet mapping program obtained coordinates for four other described locations. I converted lat/long coordinates to UTM and added this information to my spreadsheet. After converting the excel file to a DBF file I imported it into ArcGIS. I obtained a map of Sacramento county roads with addresses for ESRI and created an Address locator in ArcCatalog. Using the Geocoding tool, I was successful in mating ten locations at 100%. Further refinements of the addresses generated 11 more matches at 80%.  Further work on the map included changing the symbololgy of the sites to a larger size and to have a representation of the human body. 

Resources from  internet websites of

      US Forest Service, NAHC, ESRI

      ArcGIS 9 Software

      ESRI US Streets Geocoding Settings

      Google Earth

      Microsoft Excel, Word, Imaging

Hp Scanjet 2300

My research and work was based on the databases being kept by the NAHC. Their data is collected for tribal contacts and from the county coroner’s office. These are the forms used for recoding the information. Data received from County Coroner.

Results

The actual data is available only to the Native American Heritage Commission due to Privacy laws. Below is an example of the raw data I received from the coroner and that I turned into a data base file. The map that I have created using GIS will aid the NAHC in advanced to the use of this technology to further the mission. The greatest urgency they have is the notification of the most likely descendents of the human remains found. Most likely those remains are Nisenan, Maidu, or Miwok, but they could be from tribes with their ancestral land s origination from other parts of California.  Today people of Native American descent live all over the area, though only a small portion are of our local indigenous tribes.

UTM NORTHING

LATITUDE DD

LONGTITUDE DD

WHO FOUND

14284820.044

38.701808

 

Austin Turner

14269680.124

 

121.382039

Mark Nunnelly

 

 

 

Michael Sallee

 

A representation of the sites of discoveries of Native American human remains  populated in a table for preparation of conversion to mapable locations.

Population of Native Americans in Sacramento County area.  This represents many more people than are the likely descendants of human remains discovered. Discoveries may be from many California tribes, due to being moved during floods and changes in the creeks and river courses.

Analysis

Human remains are found in places where it is difficult to be precise about coordinates (in the rivers, in open areas away from present streets, and undeveloped construction sites.) The NAHC is obligated to keep information private about Cultural Resources and it was requested that the locations be obtained through available public information sources. It was necessary in working with Public Agencies to acquire the data to work with the agencies timeframes. The specific information on burial sites acquired and mapped will be kept confidential, not published, in compliance with State and Federal laws and per agreement between myself, Executive Secretary of the NAHC, Larry Miles and American River College instructor Paul Veisze. The format used was chosen for the purpose of producing a map that could be used for presentation purposes to further the Mission of the NAHC. My goal was to provide the visual representation requested by the Secretary for his use. There were many difficulties encountered with this project. The first that needed to be overcome was the natural reticence of the public agencies. The subject in general and the data in particular are sensitive in nature. My motivation in undertaking this project was questioned. Though respect and patience I was able to over come these inclinations and was able to complete my project and provide a valuable product to my client.

Conclusions

These are areas which have been, and often continue to be, of economic and/or religious significance to peoples today. The study and preservation of California's Native American cultural resources are important to all Californians. Archaeological and cultural resources are considered a part of the environment. The Native American Heritage Commission maintains an inventory of sites in California that are important to Native Americans, and reviews environmental impact documents to protect these sites from     damage or destruction. Mapping of these sites and a relational database that can be used for analyzing is now available.       

References
Garvin, Cosmo. What Lies Beneath-From Prehistoric Cultures to Pioneer Artifacts. Sacramento News and Review, September 15, 2003

Olsen, William H. History of a Central California Site: Or What Happened at King Brown (CA-SAC-29)

Owens, Kenneth - 1979 Historical Overview and Historical Sites of the Mother Lode Area. Submitted to BLM, Folsom District.

California Indians and the Forest Service USDA Forest Service Brochure Prepared by Pacific Southwest Region

Survey Manual www.usgs.gov/usgs-manual/500/500-6

CNAHC website http://ceres.ca.gov/nahc